This morning I was looking for a picture of The Cat in the Hat for an update on facebook. One of the links I saw was titled "The Very Un-P.C. 'Cat in the Hat' Turns 50". So being the inquisitive little bugger that I am I decided to give it a read because I wanted to know why they thought it was so un-p.c.What I found was a painfully short article where they made their point using another article that couldn't even be located. The quote the article was based around was:
"For starters, anyone need a reminder on the basic premise here? Two little kids of maybe 6 or 7 are being harassed by a large, threatening animal and its accomplices. Worse, the two have been left for an entire day without adult supervision. . . . Get the cops. Bring in a social worker and quick."
As soon as I read the article I decided to double check the definition of the term 'politically correct' because I wasn't sure that the point made was actually an issue of political correctness. I pulled my definition from the Merriam-Webster dictionary.The definition is 'conforming to a belief that language and practices which could offend political sensibilities (as in matters of sex or race) should be eliminated'. Having read the definition I do not believe that the old version of The Cat in the Hat is un-p.c. whatsoever.
I find it interesting how people are so quick to call something un-p.c. The author even goes so far as to say that this book is so politically incorrect that it probably wouldn't get published today. I guess it's easier to get all butthurt over something as innocent as a children's story than to just take it for as it is. Obviously the story is supposed to be whimsical. I really don't think that Dr. Seuss was an advocate for child neglect.
Perhaps it was the talking fish or the talking cat that made me see from a young age that this was just supposed to be fun. I don't know about anybody else but I know I get a little ticked when people decide to pick apart innocent things from my childhood. I was a smart enough kid to know that my parents would never leave me home alone before I was old enough and that if a 6 foot tall cat showed up at my door I probably shouldn't let him in.
I'm not going to take away books from my kids just because they have wild, completely impossible plots. These are the stories that I grew up with and loved. People are always going to find something to bitch about no matter what it is. In a way I feel bad if the author if the quote has kids because I'm sure he could find hundreds of things wrong with any particular kids book or movie. For that I think he is a sad little man. I'm almost more baffled that a mom agreed with him to the point where she wrote an article about it. Let your kids be kids and have their stories. Don't suck all the magic out of being a kid.